Russia Banned From Olympics By World Anti-Doping Body WADA For Four Years Over Doping
Big tax cuts may be coming for middle class in next Budget
JNU Students Lathi-Charged By Cops During Protest In Delhi Over Fee Hike
FM Sitharaman says govt will pay states' share of GST; 'compact will be honoured'
Fawad Alam Included In Pakistan Test Squad After 10 Years
4 Telangana Rape-Murder Accused Shot Dead By Cops, "Tried To Escape"
5% GST rate may be hiked to 6% as govt looks to increase revenue
Manufacturing capacity utilisation declines to 68.9% in Q2FY20, lowest since 2008
Controversial Citizenship (Amendment) Bill Cleared By Cabinet
Dale Steyn, Chris Lynn To Have Highest Base Price For IPL 2020 Auction
Kotak Mahindra, Axis Bank to hire 5,000 freshers; tech graduates top focus
Petition Filed in Supreme Court Against Pension To Politicians
Uddhav Thackeray may junk Devendra Fadnavis' bullet train, expressway, hyperloop projects
Unemployment rate falls to 7.48% in November; labour participation rate lowest since 2016
Nepal's Anjali Chand Scripts History, Claims Best T20I Bowling Figures
Uddhav Thackeray-led Shiv Sena-NCP-Cong alliance wins floor test in Maharashtra assembly
FASTag not mandatory until December 15
RBI may go for another rate cut as GDP slows to more than 6-year low
RBI Files Application To Begin Bankruptcy Proceedings Against Dewan Housing
Swiss Firm To Develop India's Biggest Airport Near Delhi, Outbids Adani

Latest Posts

RCom creditors refuse to accept Anil Ambani's resignation

On the day Reliance Communications (RCom) announced the quarterly losses of Rs 30,163 crore, its chairman Anil Ambani resigned as the director of the insolvent telco, which effectively meant resignation from chairmanship as well. Prior to and along with Ambani, five other directors of RCom had also resigned from the telco, including Ryna Karani, Chhaya Virani, Manjari Kacker, Suresh Rangachar and Manikantan V.

The committee of creditors (CoC) has rejected the resignations saying these cannot be accepted. It asked the directors, including Ambani, to perform their duties until the insolvency proceedings are concluded. However, the resignation of the other director Manikantan V., who had put in his paper on October 4, was accepted and Viswanath Devaraja Rao replaced him as director and CFO (chief financial officer).

But why did CoC reject the resignation of Ambani and four other directors? Do they have the powers to do so and how? The company law experts say that working directors or wholetime directors can be removed or resign as per the terms of their appointment, which is subject to the approval of the board. But since RCom has been admitted for insolvency, the power of the board ceases to exist, and those powers are now vested with the (RP) resolution professional (Anish Nanavaty of Deloitte). Through RP, the CoC has the authority to accept or reject resignations of the wholetime directors.

However, that is not the case with independent directors who can resign at any time without needing a formal approval from the board or CoC.

"While the execution is done by RP, the ultimate powers are with CoC. In case of RCom, as the board has no powers, the CoC is the decision-making agency currently. The executive directors have a contractual obligation, and they simply cannot walk out of the company," says Manoj Kumar, partner and head (M&A and insolvency) at Delhi-based Corporate Professionals.

The reason why CoC rejected the resignation of RCom directors is because these directors are required to attend the meetings while insolvency proceedings are underway. While they are not allowed to vote in those meetings, they are supposed to provide clarifications when sought by the CoC. If these directors are no longer holding a title in the company, they cannot be invited in the CoC meetings. Once they demit the (director's) office, they can argue that they are no longer associated with the company. So it seems logical that CoC rejected the directors' intent to exit the telco.

"If there's a need for any clarification, the committee member may ask the directors. It's a basic understanding that they should cooperate in the process, and whenever they are called, they should come and attend the meeting. The general stand is that after the company is admitted to insolvency, none of the directors should be allowed to demit the office, otherwise the purpose of insolvency gets defeated. That is the stand which might have been taken by RCom's CoC. That is a legal position, beyond that nothing is written neither in the company law or nor in the IBC (insolvency and bankruptcy code)," says a company law consultant.

There have been similar instances in the past. In 2017, for instance, two of the insolvent Amtek Auto directors had resigned from the board, but they were brought back later to ensure that they continue to handle operations. RCom, which posted record net losses of Rs 30,163 crore in the second quarter of 2019/20 owing to provisioning for AGR (adjusted gross revenues) dues, is going through insolvency proceedings after it failed to find a buyer for its assets.


Alert Message

Please Wait...

Share the Opinion Poll with your Friends At


Share the Survey with your
Friends At